Gnutella Forums

Gnutella Forums (
-   Feature Requests & Bug Reports (
-   -   File information ? (

ToNneTje January 26th, 2009 03:07 PM

File information ?
When i search for audio-files i ONLY see (bitrate) information when i found audio-files from Bearshare sources.
Is it possible to show file-information (audio & video) from Phex sources (and other sources) in a new Phex release?

That would be very nice!

Lord of the Rings January 31st, 2009 09:00 AM

I put my hand up for this one too. It is handy being able to see audio id3 tag information for (a) downloads (b) search results (c) library files

What id3 tag information can do:
Show audio file duration (time length of song)
Album (if any)

With this information it helps to (1) know you are getting what you are seeking. (b) analyze the details to check the data is correct & is not a spammed corrupt file or a mistitled file, etc.

With ability to see id3 tag information, the above information can be compared between one's library files & search results to be sure you are not downloading the same file. I find this is an issue for same title song, different version from different concert for example. It's almost impossible to know unless the file name incorporates that information, else id3 tag information can be seen.

Bitrate is more important than many people realise. ;) Being able to see bitrate also enables you to be able to choose a good quality encoding (in hope it was not recoded from another mp3), and as suggested above, compare to be sure it is not a deliberately corrupted file.

As it is, there is no show bit-rate options for the columns.

arne_bab February 1st, 2009 03:02 PM

I just went digging a bit for java id3 libraries.

The ones which sound best to me and are still active are jaudiotagger and entagged:

- Entagged | Developer

The License is LGPL in both cases, so they can be used directly.

I didn't list myID3, as its license (Apache) might conflict mith the GPlv2 - to be able to use it, Phex might have to switch to using the GPLv3 which add compatibility to the Apache license.

Lord of the Rings February 2nd, 2009 08:59 AM

Entagged also gives option for lossless formats such as FLAC & APE (I didn't realise FLAC had some vulnerabilities.) It seems Entagged has some compabitility with WAV, I hope that also includes AIFF.
I did not read the full details of jaudiotagger since I need to register at Java.

I presume with both the first two types that m4a/aac support means it also recognises Apple's Lossless format which has the same file extension. AAC support 'might' also give some information with video files. A "might" I suggest in "hope". lol :D

I would greatly look forward to this being incorporated into Phex in the future. Which one chosen is the question I guess.

Edit: Looked at some of jaudiotagger details. Glad to see the mp3 id3 tag abilities appear to be full & up to date. Also has WAV, ogg vorbis abilities.

Lord of the Rings April 6th, 2009 12:50 PM

Any idea if or when these abilities will be added? :)

Lord of the Rings July 2nd, 2009 07:49 PM

Bumps this topic. :p :D I wondered if any initial works have been tried out yet experimentally into adopting any of the above audio tag readers for both search results & library?

arne_bab July 2nd, 2009 11:54 PM

I just heard from Gregor, that he's currently stomped with real-life work, so I think it will take some time till he gets to try it.

But while we're at that: Here's something new for Phex, written by Tamara for her studies: Pootle for Phex

Lord of the Rings December 31st, 2011 01:28 AM

Bump ! :D

A file description tool which could handle multiple files at once would be golden in my opinion.

Why multiple file descriptor? Example: 300 photos from a camping trip in mountains. Can describe 130 files as being waterfalls. Describe 100 as being forest pictures, 70 photos as beach, etc.

Being able to view description of a file in search results should accompany this.

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 08:29 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0 ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.

Copyright 2015 Gnutella Forums.
All Rights Reserved.