Gnutella Forums

Gnutella Forums (https://www.gnutellaforums.com/)
-   Chat - Open Topics - The Lounge (https://www.gnutellaforums.com/chat-open-topics-lounge/)
-   -   Slipshod 'illegal' question about a (Movie) (https://www.gnutellaforums.com/chat-open-topics-lounge/36376-slipshod-illegal-question-about-movie.html)

capnrob April 12th, 2005 03:22 AM

Slapshot (Movie)
 
This is a nifty old Paul Nueman movie about a 3rd rate hockey team. I'd love to get a copy of it. If anyone out would like to share you'd make my day. Have searched repeatedly but it's not on here. Video store doesn't have it either.

Thanks all.

zookeeper007 April 12th, 2005 11:19 AM

Hey, I've got it, but it's on VHS...sorry, it's of no help to you unless you can figure out how I can transfer a VHS movie onto my computer to share.

capnrob April 12th, 2005 09:39 PM

RULES?!? EGADS! We file sharers certainly wouldn't want to violate anyone's precious rules now would we boys and girls?

A thousand pardons Oh Mighty Moderator! Please inform your poor, ignorant subjects; is it against the rules (unruley?) to ask for something you couldn't find by searching for it?







"Listen Bug, don't try to out-wierd me. I get stranger things than you with my breafast cereal."

--Z.B.

zookeeper007 April 13th, 2005 07:47 AM

Sorry folks, didn't mean to offend, nor did I intend to break any rules. [Edit] really is a classic movie, even here on the West Coast of the Great White North - tho the fools here know squat about hockey!

arne_bab April 13th, 2005 08:01 AM

@capnrob: Try reading the forum rules. Talk about "movies to get" and similar is dangerous to the forum itself, for it could be forced to close down by some fraggin lawyers in teh entertainment industry, if these topics get discussed here. Try forums, which are concerned with the files-side of filesharing. This forum is about the softwares with which the Gnutella Network works (about most of the Gnutella-Clients you can get), and we want to be able to keep it online for a long time.

We supply a platform to get and provide support for the programs, and as such Gnutellaforums is much more useful (imnsho) than as a files-forum, which might get closed down sooner or later.

ursula April 20th, 2005 09:03 AM

many thanks, arne_bab !!!

Well put !

Be a bit silly to threaten this great help site just to aid a few folks who have not yet figured out how to answer some of their own 'search' questions, hmmm ?


:rolleyes:

And, SMs should NOT participate in assisting in illegal activities...

RIGHT, et voilá ?????????????????????????????????

:rolleyes:

et voilà April 20th, 2005 03:14 PM

Damn Urs, I know what I'm talking about :rolleyes: The movie isn't available to buy from everywhere, except maybe from ebay auctions or collectors!!! It's from 1977. Now, I'll tell you to shut up gently, gracias, you're not funny :mad:

Oh, and I think we talked about deleting other SM posts in the mod forum enough, this is clearly an exemple of crap moderating from your side.

Des fois il y a du monde qui aiment exaspérer les autres....

cathodraytube April 21st, 2005 12:12 AM

it would be differant if it was a new relese movie . i and moast other people wouldent see anything wrong with d/l ing a movie that old ....its basecley no differant from just seeing it or tapeing it off of TV. its the new releses the mpaa is worried about losing money on and not the movies that have been all but forgotten and that wouldent make any more revenue any way. allsow the vast magorety of people who download music and movies dont have the cash to buy the dvds/tapes/cds ect anyway. so the recording industry isent losing any money anyway because the people wouldent buy anything even in the abcence of fileshareing. but the riaa/mpaa cant get that thru there dence heads so there just going to be greedy and ignorant about it. btw i love what capnrob sed! rules are made to be broken.....

arne_bab April 21st, 2005 07:39 AM

Seems I'll have to write a disclaimer:

I am in no way against the sharing of any material you see fit.

Sharing is, what keeps any p2p-network running, and downloading older movies is legal in germany, where I live (but sadly not resharing them it seems), but even the matter of legality is no deal for me at all.

There are some legal risks, but judging from the number of Users p2p-networks have and the number of sued people, you still have a very slim chance of getting into problems (less than 0.1%).

The only Problem when discussing this here is: This forum is well known, and it is surely also well known to the RIAA/MPAA, so they will look for any chance to shut it down (because that would destroy a resource for Gnutella, weakening teh support for the users).

We don't want to give them this chance.

Share what you think right, at any time and any place, but please don't talk about files in here.

The rules are there for a reason. If you are against that reason (keeping this forum alive and safe from lawyers), then you can sure break the rules, but remember, that you are then actively attacking something into which the mods in here have put much time and effort, and expect a corresponding answer.

ukbobboy01 April 22nd, 2005 12:06 PM

arne_bab

It's a shame that you have to explain the obvious to people, it seems that even the simplest of things, such as the MPAA looking for any legal reason close down this forum, have to be set out and drummed into the minds of selfish or (deliberately) ignorant people.

To all those that don't know, the sharing of copyright material without any recompense to the copyright holder is illegal, the age of the material is irrelevant.
If a person is going to use, as a defense, that he only shares old materials that he cannot buy in the shops he will get short shrift from any judge hearing the case. There are online stores that sell old stuff, and at less than a US dollar or UK pound a song there really is no excuse for people to set themselves up for the MPAA to pounce (or attack this forum).




UK Bob

cathodraytube April 22nd, 2005 07:05 PM

all i was trying to say is that the recording industry is a manopoly . and now with the advent of fileshare there trying to scare you into buying over priced stuff. if they would change there ways and quit ripping people off and sell movies and music at a resonabul price ,like single songs for 50cents each on mini cd or flash memory or something and movies for like 5 bucks each on a formatt that wasent designed to fail (DVDs)in an attempt to make you re-buy the same movie 25000 times. if that where the case id run out and BUY every song and every movie i ever wanted. until that happens 1000000s of people are going to continue to "rip back" allso im terribley sorry if iv offended anyone or jeperdized the forums by trying to prove a point.

zookeeper007 April 23rd, 2005 08:43 AM

well it looks like I'm not the only one missing the 45's from the '50s - '70s. I don't think they were 50 cents even back then, but yeah, it would be nice to buy songs that cheap again!

arne_bab April 24th, 2005 03:22 AM

@cathodraytube no problem with that. I understand your reasons to the fullest, and if you let yourself get carried away: That can happen sometimes.

No gripes, anyhow. :)

Besides: What you buy gives them money to go against you, so the best way is to buy only from bands and labels, which don't support going against filesharing (though they are few) and getting your friends to do the same. And not to forget: telling them (and if you have a homepage: everyone who visits it) that you don't buy from anyone who attacks filesharing.

And if you want to do even more, think about supporting

http://contentflatrate.org/

It is about legalizing all filesharing with a simple flat-tax on any form of getting music and movies online and got quite some momentum in germany during the last year.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 10:45 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0 ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.

Copyright © 2020 Gnutella Forums.
All Rights Reserved.