Will RIAA attempts to shut down broadband ISPs be the death of P2P?
 

With each passing day more and more talk is generated of the RIAA getting broadband ISPs shut off for P2P users.
Here are a few examples
http://www.boycott-riaa.com/article/4678
http://www.gnutella.com/forums/gnutellastop/145
http://www.bearshare.net/forum/showt...threadid=11536

Will this trigger a fear in P2P users that, combined with the SSSCA bill, will signal the ultimate victory of the RIAA and MPAA?
Personally, I'm surprised these corporations have the brass to go after individual users, which is a move I'm sure will hurt there public relations once this information goes mainstream.
Is this how it all ends? :(

The commercial corporations on Gnutella are the problem, including the ISPs. They are the weak link and the RIAA knows it.

1. Run a open source client
2. Push developers to write code that prevents the RIAA and ISPs from knowing what files you are sharing.

The commercial Gnutella client developers won't do it because its a law suit waiting to happen if they make a program that allow people to hide things.
Support open source clients any way you can.

There is such a thing as unregistered #2 described. it is called freenet. It is possible gnutella may fall in the coming year. But our loss will be the invincible freenet's gain.

any further thoughts on this?

Link to another thread
 

This thread also discusses this issue:

http://www.gnutellaforums.com/showth...threadid=10761

Also, here is a petition to stop DMCA - not exactly comprehensive arguments, but so far the only one I have found. Any lawyers out there want to draft up a better petition to fight the sweeping raft of new copyright legislation seeking to take away our 'fair use' access to the culture of the 20th century?

http://www.PetitionOnline.com/stopdmca/

Could sure do with some signatures! Anyone know of any other actions that can be taken, other petitions etc?

Nos

<I>"We gonna kick those crazy bald-heads out of town." --- Bob ****** 1976</I>

I supppose this is the topic that everyone but Nosferatu is too scared to discuss?

They can't shut Gnutella down .
Even if they managed to shut down all the hostcaches , you suddenly have 50 people standing up saying : hey I got a T1 , how do I run a hostcache ?

And when they shut those down it will start over again .
I wonder how long it will take before the record companies give up ?

Actually it is quite simple to shut gnutella down since it's very vulnerable to DOS attacks.

If you DOS one client , the clients it's connected to will see the connection timeout and simply drop it . This drops them below their set number of connections and they wil look for new connections with other clients .
Thus that one unfortunate client that got DOSed gets kicked of the network but the network will recover to optimal condition in no time .

It's indeed easy to DOS one client but not the network .
You can't compare a DOS attack against a single computer or server with an attack against an complex network like Gnutella .

Gnucleus has a new way to use web servers as host caches, so that's not a problem any more.