You make me laugh :p
GnucDNAr2 is BOTH G1 AND G2
imagine your "so perfect world"
Morpheus was kicked of kazaa.. they needed a network fast.. they started to develop their own gnutella implementation :D whahahhahahahaha
in that case Gnutella would be dead already.. maybe GnucDNA is not as good or as updated as you like... i get my files with it.. do i care i start as an ultrapeer? NO i just receive my files, and i am happy with it.
I don't like limewire java **** hogging resources on my system. I like bearshare though. i can't judge GTK-gnutella though, i don't use linux atm

You? No, as Trustyfiles users, ayzoo, users , morpheus users, gnucleus users, kiwi alpha users, webspider users, mynapster users.... and ton of others. But they take the foreign slots of LW (limited to 3 out of 32). Those slots are for having a better connectivity with other network parts such as bearshare and gtk-gnutella, once a buggy gnucDNA with automatic UP starts, it do not let this connectivity happens (they are only there to get results, then leech). That the biggest flaw of gnucDNA: the UP election scheme and it has been since 1.8 (UP support). Now that 32 outdegree is in gnucdna, I see Trustyfiles 2.2 starting as UP and then getting 32 other UP connections (mostly Limewires) and it doesn't have any leaf, this is what I call network harming big time.

Tell to John that UP selection is important because he doesn't seem to understand that. I mean with a proper UP selection theme, people would have realized that gnucDNA sucks already and wouldn't be using apps with this core (they would for g2).

Edit: hahaha Morph knew 6 months before that kazaa would kick them... That makes nearly 3 years (2 years and 3 months +6 months) if they would have devs, they would have created something, not only including other opensource apps (and the Neo which comes from an university).

LoL at Morph devs!!!:D :D