I'm happy, for now, with iTunes 2
but I also prefer LW 1.7 (which didn't have a player)
over any of the more recent LW's (including LW 2.3.3 Pro)

I'm guessing that you don't like iTunes or iTunes 2(?)

There are several other Mac mp3 players available;
some are free (basic) like iTunes;
but if you want to be able to create special sound tweaks
or make your own (special) mixes,
you will likely have to pay for a player and the extra features.