My recommendation is that you read this entire thread as this argument has already been made and concluded. You should also read this thread
http://www.gnutellaforums.com/showth...threadid=21176
Semantic rationalization are used often by people who wish to twist issues by trying to argue something from some strange an irrelevant angle. This is not to suggest that people do it on purpose however, some do. It just reflects a person ability to reason effectively.